Overall I will give this jacket 4 stars because there are a few issues I have found. I have used this jacket in both rain and cold and it performs remarkable well in both. Warm and dry when I arrive at my destination, cold as low as 20 ° F. However a few issues i have, the first being that the zippers are flimsy as my one sleeve zip has already broken at the tab because the metal is too thin in my opinion. I believe it could and should be more stout. Secondly, i have an issue with the venting. Now i realize this jacket is primarily wet/ cold use but in PA you can leave for work in the a.m. and have it be warm enough in the afternoon to need ventilation and there really isn't enough. There are no back zips to extract air and the front vents are poorly placed as they are on the shoulders and are basically covered by my backpack straps so little to any air flows in. I think the front vents would be better suited on the arms or further down the chest.